Scheldt '44 - Realism versus Playability?

[Liebchen]

That is not what I am saying.  Right now, you could choose not to, but, your opp can.  In reality, Cdrs don't get replays before deciding what to do.  As an optional rule like I am talking about, is both players can watch or both players cannot watch.  It's just another way to play.

I don't think that a replay is any more cheating than watching your troops in combat in real time, getting action reports on the radio, etc.

While I don't always watch replays, in some situations (Smolensk, say) not watching the replays can lead to forced errors, such as moving into contact with a formation that your troops saw and knew was there, but that may have moved out of sight before the end of the turn.