A Close Run Thing - The Matrix Games version of West Front

There are 8 comments

A Close Run Thing

By von Earlmann

15 - 6 - 16 Axis

Download

Rating:	8.77 (29)
Games Played:	37
SM:	9
Turns:	45
Type:	Custom
First Side:	Allies
Second Side:	Axis
Downloads:	667

Version 1.02 and is best played against human opponent(s) and is designed for team play. Scenario covers the first 5 days of the Salerno landings.It begins with the initial landings and ends just prior to the arrival of the British Armored Division

Player Voting Stats
Member	Balance	Enjoyment
Von Earlmann	Slightly Pro Allies	9
Joachim Peiper	Slightly Pro Axis	8
Peiper	Slightly Pro Axis	9
Sergent Bourgogne	Well Balanced	10
Sergent Bourgogne	Well Balanced	10

Player Voting Stats

Member

Balance

Enjoyment

Slightly Pro Allies

Slightly Pro Axis

Slightly Pro Axis

Well Balanced

Well Balanced

Show Complete Player Voting Stats

Gaming Records
1st Side Player	2nd Side Player	Result	Score
	Schwerpunkt75	vs.	dawags	Allies Minor Loss	36	81
	Dan Caviness	vs.	Tiger 88	Axis Major Victory	81	14
	dawags	vs.	Laza	Axis Major Victory	108	18
	Panzerjaeger	vs.	Scud	Axis Minor Victory	81	36
	kernel t	vs.	JRTXX	Allies Major Victory	108	18

Gaming Records

1st Side Player

2nd Side Player

Result

Score

vs.

vs.

vs.

108

vs.

vs.

108

Show Complete Gaming Records

Jeepster777

One of the best large scenario's I have ever played.....great for a teamgame.The highground LOS elevations really make it interesting...

Jim von Krieg

Lots of aircraft, but limited impact because of their ineffectiveness. Lots of artillery and it plays a significant part in the battle. Draw back is the known allied naval gun locations which are plastered by German artillery essentially sinking a large percentage of the Allied Navy. Rangers and Commandos are very ineffective. They need stiffening from line units or they will collapse fairly quickly.

Death~Dealer

Both sides have a generous force mix with abundant heavy artillery batteries- surely leading to inevitable (and entertaining) slugfests. Available smoke levels seem a bit too high for comfort, otherwise this is a very fun battle.

Armored Inferno

All three sectors are a challenge. Very enjoyable

JRTXX Mon Aug 10, 2015 12:55 am

Given the brilliant play of Kernal T,,, wiping my troops out everywhere I think I lost this one around the half way,,, my only complaint is the late and super long distance my reinforcements came in,, never could stop his momentum

Scud Frid Sep 30, 2016 4:58 pm

Lost my draw right at the end, but could have held it with a bit more caution...but where the fun in that? :) Fun scenario and challenging for both sides.

Resolve then, that on this very ground, with small flags waving and tinny blasts on tiny trumpets, we shall meet the enemy, and not only may he be ours, he may be us. --Walt Kelly

Dan Caviness Frid Dec 28, 2018 1:56 pm

It's an Earl scenario so expectations are high going in. That said, this one feels like it may require a bit of work, but is a good layout and has promise IMO. Some will find it disconcerting as it's ruthlessly historical. Our Allied opponents surrendered after 20 turns or so. I have not played this as Allied. The map is large and you have more territory then you have troops to cover. Choices must be made. This is the bones of a good if not great scenario.

Regards,

Dan

Schwerpunkt75 Sat Aug 20, 2022 2:52 am

The elevation interval (50 meters) creates some interesting challenges. Achieving surprise for either player is impossible due to observation. Good but sometimes frustrating map. Rivers restrict and funnel operations into certain areas. Between two equally capable players, an Axis victory is likely; draw is the best that Allied player can hope for.