CW First Clash - Combat Mission: Battle For Normandy

There are 7 comments

CW First Clash

By George MC

1 - 8 - 3

Download

Rating:	8.66 (14)
Games Played:	12
SM:	6
Turns:	70
Type:	Custom
First Side:	Axis
Second Side:	Allies
Downloads:	491

German and Polish recce units probing ahead of their main units and seeking suitable river crossing clash.

Player Voting Stats
Member	Balance	Enjoyment
A Canadian Cat	Well Balanced	6
Comdr	Moderately Pro Axis	7
Barre	Well Balanced	8
BletchleyGeek	Well Balanced	8
BletchleyGeek	Well Balanced	8

Player Voting Stats

Member

Balance

Enjoyment

Well Balanced

Moderately Pro Axis

Well Balanced

Well Balanced

Well Balanced

Show Complete Player Voting Stats

Gaming Records
1st Side Player	2nd Side Player	Result	Score
	Panzer Lehr	vs.	TeddyA	Draw	36	36
	Stonecutter	vs.	Kil Roy	Allies Tactical Victory	54	18
	Baluka1974	vs.	Guardsman	Draw	36	36
	Hussar_63	vs.	Baluka1974	Draw	36	36
	Hussar_63	vs.	Baluka1974	Draw	36	36

Gaming Records

1st Side Player

2nd Side Player

Result

Score

vs.

vs.

Allies Tactical Victory

vs.

vs.

vs.

Show Complete Gaming Records

A Canadian Cat

Concerned about the scoring

Author of: Whose Turn Is It? - http://www.lesliesoftware.com/products/WhoseTurnIsIt / CMFI Sicily Pathfinders(not playable H2H) / CMBS Opportunity Knocks (scenarios, maps and mods here)

Comdr

Not sure if I played badly or if my armour was out matched by the Axis armour

Barre

The scoring system for this scenario is abit confusing in my opinion, but still a great scenario.

BletchleyGeek

See comments regarding scoring - it would be good that the scenario notes are ammended to reflect that scoring is better determined by applying the rules in the manual and Windows calculator :)

Hussar_63 Sun Sep 17, 2017 2:24 pm

Comments about broken scoring are 100% correct and takes the fun out of playing this scenario. Played mirror match with Baluka and in both games the Polish units were completely decimated yet we both ended with draws. Also this scenario is way too long could be cut short to 45 minutes with +/- of 10.

Stonecutter Mon Dec 19, 2022 6:44 pm

A very good, small scenario with a mix of objectives. My only suggestion would be to decrease the bonus points for each side as 1000 points seems excessive in a battle of this size.