• Blitz Shadow Player
  • Caius
  • redboot
  • Rules
  • Chain of Command
  • Members
  • Supported Ladders & Games
  • Downloads


Combat Calculations - what do I miss here?
09-27-2014, 02:51 PM, (This post was last modified: 09-28-2014, 09:33 AM by BigDuke66.)
#1
Feedback Needed  Combat Calculations - what do I miss here?
In my attempts to get a grip of the engine I tested some things, that was a nice way to find out that an extended line 3-rank infantry fires at 100% effectiveness, of course without any modification it seems to be of no relevance to mention this but for the sake of completeness it would have been very handy to mention that at all.


Now next problem is an extended 2 rank infantry, manual states:
- 2-Rank Infantry units in normal Line or Extended Line formation fire at 50% increased effectiveness.
- 2-Rank Infantry units in Shortened Line Formation fire at 75% effectiveness.

Now I made a little test in the Eagle scenario of Austerlitz but the result that I get out for the Extended line don't fit my calculation and I don't know why.

[Image: attachment.php?aid=4150]
Situation is that 748 men in Shortened line formation fire with British Muskets on a French Column
Men 748
Musket Fire Power 6
748*6= 4488 Combat Value
Combat Value 4488
2-Rank Infantry units in Shortened Line Formation fire at 75% effectiveness.
Infantry fire against Infantry in Column or Square formation is increased by 25%.
This means 75%*125%=93,75%
Modifier 0,9375
Combat Value 4488*Modifier 0,9375 = 4207,5 Effective Combat Value
Effective Combat Value 4207,5
Now you see the calculation fits to the result achieved in the game.


[Image: attachment.php?aid=4149]
Situation is that 402 men in Extended line formation fire with British Muskets on a French Column
Men 402
Musket Fire Power 6
402*6= 2412 Combat Value
Combat Value 2412
2-Rank Infantry units in normal Line or Extended Line formation fire at 50% increased effectiveness.
Infantry fire against Infantry in Column or Square formation is increased by 25%.
This means 75%*175%=131,25%
Modifier 1,3125
Combat Value 2412*Modifier 1,3125 = 3165,75 Effective Combat Value
Effective Combat Value 3165,75
You see the result calculated is not even close to the result in the game.
In the game we have 2261 as Fire Value and that is only achieved by using the same 0,9375 modifier as if the British formation was a Shortened line.
I assume that the sentence "2-Rank Infantry units in normal Line or Extended Line formation fire at 50% increased effectiveness." could be interpret wrong by me and the vocal point could be 50% increase from what?
What base value is used that is now increased by 50%?
Anyone got a clue how the calculation is done?
Or is this a bug?


Attached Files
.jpg   2-rank Extended British vs. French Column.jpg (Size: 195.64 KB / Downloads: 440)
.jpg   2-rank Shortened British vs. French Column.jpg (Size: 177.01 KB / Downloads: 494)
Quote this message in a reply


Messages In This Thread
Combat Calculations - what do I miss here? - by BigDuke66 - 09-27-2014, 02:51 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)