2012 Ladder scoring has problems

[Otto von Blotto]

And also if contributions like testing require reward does it mean there should be pints fordonations, i.e. 1. Dollar per point? I do not think so .... But still both are just 2 different way of contributing to the benefit of the club one might argue.

I think this is very different and I think you do to so I'm not sure what you were trying to prove with this statement.?

For me it's bad enough everyone on a ladder knowing when a donation is made as I believe donations to things and what someone does with there money is their affair and no one else's. This point did stop me giving a donation to the club for a long while..

To think that anyone could buy there way without any effort is bad enough but to think anyone else could look up how much was given in a bonus points award is pretty distasteful and I would think would stop any donations to the club at all.

As you say you already use ELO and win loss and are not really bothered, I am at a loss to understand why you think it's such a big thing that warrants polls, comparisons, analysis and further in-depth discussions. ?