2012 Ladder scoring has problems

[PawelM]

The fact that something has been in place for years does not make it best by default. I suppose the discussion between members who would want to see ladder points to be purely competetive or awarded for myriad of activites could be endless.

Personally I would prefere the ladder to be competetive item overall in terms of points ELO and win ratio. Again this is personal preference and other may have a different oppinion which I respect. Membership in the clube does not oblidge to have a single oppinion on the game and how things are to be dealt with in the club.

I think bonuses for testin are relatively high. 20 x SM and then again for sugmitting the report means effectively 40x SM. Given that major win is 12 xSM this gives more than 3:1 ratio for test game vs a "normal" game.

I would be interested in seeing a poll in the forum too see what people thing about this.

Could I request moderators to arrange poll with 2 question like this:

1. Do you think ladder points should be awarded purely for competetive games?
A. Yes
B. No
C. I do not care

2. Do you think the bonuses for game testing are too high?

A. Yes
B. No
C. I do not care

I am not asking for any action beyond that, but i think it would be an interesting poll.