Extreme assault?

[Jumbo]

Some nice points Frank. I mentioned earlier when this thread started up. I am fine with both 1.02 and Extreme assault since players have the option to select one or the other. Assaults did fail from time to time in real life even when the odds were dramatically in favor of the attacker. With 1.02 that would almost never happen. With Extreme assault it appears from threads that it's happening more often than seems historically accurate or realistic. It's very conceivable in real life that high quality troops with good morale that have even taken some serious blows would or could hold out against a much larger force of poor/fair quality troops with average or below average morale that are attacking fresh. There are numerous historical accounts of stuff like that happening in the past. On the other side of that, It wouldn't be so incredible or unusual for poor/fair quality troops that have average or below average moral and even fresh on top of it getting assaulted by higher quality troops who are tired and even fewer in number and losing. Assaulting successfully is very dependent on the quality and moral of the troops involved. Numbers of course are important along with weapons mix. In CS games I feel it should be somewhat unusual for disrupted troops of fair to poor quality and moral holding on against good quality forces with good moral and with decent assault values. That even with the defenders out numbering the attackers. Now if the defenders have been disrupted but are of good quality/moral and decent defense value, I don't see any problem with them holding on for a bit if being assaulted by troops of less quality/moral and a not so special assault value. If I recall with version 1.02 this would almost never happen if defender was disrupted regardless of quality/moral of defender versus attacker (not entirely realistic at all). And if fair/poor quality forces with average moral that are all ready disrupted are holding on against superior quality forces with better moral and even numbers in their favor. Well that's not to realistic either IMO. Has that been happening a lot with extreme assault?. If so, Some on should really take a serious look into that one. I have not played enough games as late to know that. I'm only commenting on other players observations and my few experiences with EA