Extreme assault?

[Hawk Kriegsman]

Huibs post sums it up nicely.

Agreed.

Expecting old tactics to work, then being upset when they don't.

Agreed.

It is a broad "You".

I figured as much.

And after I offered advice, you found excellent force mixes and succeeded exceptionally with 1.04 rules.

I have succeeded better. Not exceptionally. I am not at the claimed 60 to 70% with the right force mix. I am not at the 20% either.

If I had to guess I would say I am around 30 to 40% with proper forces.

Hardly. I'm saying it is not nearly as horrible as it is being made out to be.

Again the majority are not saying its horrible. What is being said it is too hard and not as good as it could be.

IMHO it needs to be brought up to a legitimate 75 to 85% with the right force mix without the 10% auto fail and with a 90% likelyhood of losses to one or both sides (irrespective of the defender being dislodged).

I think this will have the effect of actually having an over all 60 to 70% success rate for all assaults (whether or not you have the right force mix) with some sort of tangible result (meaning SP loses) 90% of the time.

Maybe the same can be said for the 1.04 Extreme Assault rules?

In many cases yes sure.

But in my case and many others...no.

I get how they work, I understand how they work and do as you have suggested in all assaults.

I do not get the 60 to 70% advertised result.

Thanx!

Hawk