Rating scenarios without any self reflection

[Von Luck]

Now no arguaments here just my point of view on this one.I for one appreciate ALL work done by members who take the time to bring out new scenarios for members etc to play.Now the downside please dont take all negative comments to heart maybe they just want it rebalanced a little more turns more units less units etc.I think they whole idea of playtesting is to get the scenario up to a decent level where both sides have a fair chance of winning.This obviously cant take into account someone like Oberst playing a Rookie but its meant for the average player i think.The whole idea of H2H Testing is to get feedback on the scenario and make changes if needed.Now the H2H section ASKS for comments on the game ie to large is the map look ok etc so they are put in to try and help the Hard working desingers improve their work.Granted any nasty ones shouldnt be included(not refering to this post) just in general.