Rating scenarios without any self reflection

[Mike Abberton]

I think if a scenario is being tested in the h2h productions, the playtester has an obligation to try and provide constructive criticism. That is the whole point of playtesting, to improve the scenario before general release.

However, if you are simply playing a scenario that you picked off that ladder for a game, than a comment might be intended as a suggestion to the designer on how to improve it, or it could be intended as a recommendation to play it or not for other members of the club, or a bunch of other reasons. The tone and content of those comments would be quite different.

Mike