Rating scenarios without any self reflection

[Herr Straße Laufer]

Good points Cole.
Normally I would not have commented, in this thread, at all.
But, the header "Rating scenarios without any self reflection" seemed to imply something the designer wanted to put forth that ruffled my feathers. A subtle put down?

How about a little designer "self reflection"?
How about a little designer understanding that the comments reflected the "experience of the individual player"?

As Hawk stated, this has come up before.
As you stated, you enjoyed the scenario and appreciated that minor countries were represented.

My guess is that the designer will not take his own advice and use a little "reflection" to see that there are negatives and positives in all scenario designs. Focus on the one negative and he will not be able to enjoy any positives?
As Hawk pointed out, the majority of comments were solidly positive.

Ed