Can we go back?

[Digger]

Yet Again I find myself supporting Huib.

I look at Win/loss percentage when assessing the balance of the scenario. Though with the experiences of the current Shark Fin Soup tourney this is also pretty much irrelevant, as skill levels play a significant part in the perceived balance of the scenario.

I like the star system as I think it is the easiest to use, and has pretty much become a universal method of rating things, from I-tunes, Amazon to this site.

My wish list would be to

a. Ditch the Old rating system entirely
b. Fix up the averaging issue on the star system
c. Fix up the Javascript window for the star system for the ones that are broken
d. Re-enable Scenario Voting without having to report a game
e. On the report game window, make it more obvious that you can write comments in the comments field. At the moment the whole area is shaded and you can't TAB into it which makes it look like YOU can't write in the field. SO make it WHITE, with a character limit and a scroll bar.

I am sure that if the star sytem was fixed and was reliable and was the only option then it would be used and would service the club exceptioanlly well.

Matt