If you test this way don't test at all

[Huib Versloot]

Montana,

It is not meant personal. In fact the reason I posted what I did after having gotten a lot of such test reports by various members who no doubt all had the best intentions.

For me it doesn't even really matter as I can fall back on many seasoned testers such as Nort, Don, Cam and many more, even without the H2H testing facility. However for new designers it is critical to get detailed feedback from H2H section testers.

If the H2H section continues to give feedback this way, it will become useless and designers will stop using it or worse; new designers will give up entirely.

It seems the H2H section will be updated these days. Let's hope that with some better questions in the test form and the possibility of reading other people's reports the thing will be moving in the right direction.

Huib