McNamara db question for Volcano Man

[Shoopzee]

Well my current interest is for F40, which I think some players shy away from. I know David G is working on playtesting a new oob, and making some changes, which I'm sure will be great stuff. I'm not sure to what extent they are changing any of the unit values. I know that most people are saying they feel the German units are too strong. As you indicated though some of the McNamara changes apply more to later war periods especially in AFV and AT assets.

I think what David is covering will improve the game, especially with a new Belgian oob, well researched.

My interest in F40 is more what if. What if Girards army group was not moved to the coastal flank for use in the Dyle plan, but left in the Rheims area as a mobile reserve, which it initially was. Also, what about a premature winter attack, which almost took place.

My question to you would be, while playtesting F40, did you ever feel that a some changes could have been made to the unit parameters, a la the McNamara DB treatment? I think its a great game that is getting ingnored by some, but not all. As always, thanks Ed. Cheers Ted.